Design and Engineering Forum 
[Home] [Design Resources] [Technology Store] 
[Archive#1] [Archive #2] [Archive #3] [Calculators] 

Force required to bend a tube suspension link...  
Post Reply  Forum 
Posted by: astroracer ^{®} 03/01/2004, 14:31:18 Author Profile Mail author Edit 
I have a problem I am working on. I want to determine the amount of force a 1 1/2 o.d. x 1/4 wall D.O.M tube can withstand before bending. The tube is the lower link in a four link suspension on the back of a 3300 lb truck. It is 36" long with the front pivot located to the frame with a rod end. The rear is attached to the rearend with a rod end. The truck is lifted with airbags which sit between this lower bar and the frame. The rear most bag mount (welded to the bar) is 20" from the rearend (lever arm). I figure the weight distribution is pretty close to 50/50 so I am using 1650lbs to calculate the loads. I've included a sketch which will hopefully clarify the problem. I am worried about the bar bending during hard suspension hits and /or work hardening and breaking. Are my fears justified and what kind of forces will this bar withstand before it loses it's elasticity and bends perminently or stresses and breaks. Thanks in advance for any help. 
Post Reply  Recommend  Alert  Rate  View All   Next  
Replies to this message 
Is this really all that difficult?  
Re: Force required to bend a tube suspension link...  astroracer  Post Reply  Top of thread  Forum 
Posted by: astroracer ^{®} 03/04/2004, 13:31:34 Author Profile Mail author Edit 
I know this will take some serious caculations. I am not a mechanical engineer, I am a designer. I can see some inherent strength problems with this design but would like to have some real world numbers to prove it to a friend... Any help would be greatly appreciated and I can help if more info is needed. Thanks Mark 
Post Reply  Recommend  Alert  Rate  Where am I? Original Top of thread    
Re: Is this really all that difficult?  
Re: Is this really all that difficult?  astroracer  Post Reply  Top of thread  Forum 
Posted by: ReubenAG ^{®} 03/10/2004, 16:24:37 Author Profile Mail author Edit 
The calcs for this are not too difficult  the link can be approximated as a simply supported beam. I converted all your imperial units to metric  the force applied creates a bending moment of approx 2000 MPa (about 290 ksi) for a tube of the given dimensions. I don't know what steel you are using, but ordinary mild steel yields (deforms permanently) at anywhere between 200 and 250 Mpa (35 ksi). The drawing directions are also not clear  is this link a trailing arm type link or a link in a double wishbone (aarm) setup. Normal convention for vehicles is to put x positive forwards, y positive left and z positive up. Also some clarity  when you talk about a 3300 lb truck do you mean a truck carrying a 3300 lb load, or the truck and load has a mass of 3300 lb? 
Post Reply  Recommend  Alert  Rate  Where am I? Original Top of thread    
Re: Is this really all that difficult?  
Re: Re: Is this really all that difficult?  ReubenAG  Post Reply  Top of thread  Forum 
Posted by: astroracer ^{®} 03/11/2004, 13:42:39 Author Profile Mail author Edit 
Hey Rueben, Thanks for responding. The link is a trailing arm. This is a 4 link style rear suspension with two lower links and two upper links all mounted with rod ends. The mat'l is 1 1/2" O.D. x .25 Wall D.O.M. steel tubing (mild steel). The pic I provided has "X" positive to the left BUT... I work in GM on Unigraphics V18 and UG has the Coordinates all backwards as it was an airplane design program at one time. X+ is rearward. Y+ is out the passenger side door and Z+ is upward. Anyway... the front of the truck is to the right in the pic... The total mass of the truck (it won't carry any kind of load) is approximately 33003400 lbs. I figure 50% of the weight will be on the lower link with the bags aired up. This is the 1650lbs. I have indicated in the pic. This is a static load... not taking into account the loads induced when hitting a pothole or speed bump at speed. Thank you for helping. Mark 
Post Reply  Recommend  Alert  Rate  Where am I? Original Top of thread    
Re: Is this really all that difficult?  
Re: Re: Is this really all that difficult?  astroracer  Post Reply  Top of thread  Forum 
Posted by: ReubenAG ^{®} 03/20/2004, 15:09:30 Author Profile Mail author Edit 
Even if you assume that the 1650 lbf carried by the rear axle is spread over two rear links, the yield strength of the links would be exceeded. In any situation such as this, it is a good idea to place the air bag, spring or whatever is used to support the load as close as possible to the point of application of the load. This minimises the bending moment (torque) experienced by the link. Sometimes vehicle designers have to attach the spring element some distance from where the load comes in due to space considerations  however, I am struggling to see why one would want to mount the spring as far from the axle as in your sketch. 
Post Reply  Recommend  Alert  Rate  Where am I? Original Top of thread    
Bending loads  
Re: Re: Is this really all that difficult?  ReubenAG  Post Reply  Top of thread  Forum 
Posted by: astroracer ^{®} 03/22/2004, 12:44:04 Author Profile Mail author Edit 
Reuben, This is not my design... I am trying to explain to a young man why this is not a good idea. The reason for the excessive distance from the load is so the bag will provide more "height", or lift, when it is aired up. This is not a requirement for the suspension to work but a vanity thing. I guess you are only as cool as the height of your truck when aired up.... I know this is not a good design but explaining it to some of these young "builders" is tough if I don't know how you got the numbers you came up with. If you could possibly run through the calculations for me I would really appreciate it. Thank You Mark 
Post Reply  Recommend  Alert  Rate  Where am I? Original Top of thread    
Re: Bending loads  
Re: Bending loads  astroracer  Post Reply  Top of thread  Forum 
Posted by: ReubenAG ^{®} 03/25/2004, 09:40:11 Author Profile Mail author Edit 
You had already shown how to find to bending moment (torque to some) at the point where the air bag attaches to the strut. Given a bending moment M, the maximum stress in any beam Stress = concentration factor x Bending moment x distance from centre of area to top of beam / second moment of area Some of the terms in this are a little obscure this is the general form for calculating stresses in a beam which is not necessarily circular or even symmetrical. For the simplified case of a beam of circular cross section and thickness t, the following is true: Distance from centre of area to top of beam = Outer radius

Post Reply  Recommend  Alert  Rate  Where am I? Original Top of thread 
Powered by Engineers Edge
© Copyright 2000  2018, by Engineers Edge, LLC All rights reserved. Disclaimer