Design and Engineering Forum

 True Position Tolerance VS Callout Tolerance Post Reply Forum
 Posted by: brice arnold ® 12/09/2005, 17:33:27 Author Profile Mail author Edit I have a drawing with a hole position callout of .001". I spoke with a machine shop about the production of this part and they informed me the the true position tolerance for a .001" callout is actually .0003565". Upon asking about this he could not go into detail but informed be that it is a fairly common factor (.3565) which is applied to positioning tolerance and involves a series of calculations. Is there anyone familiar with this factor, that could offer a better explination? Also, does anyone know of a source for these calculations? I have some simple GD&T booklets which make no mention of this factor. Modified by brice arnold at Fri, Dec 09, 2005, 17:34:57

 Replies to this message

 Re: True Position Tolerance VS Callout Tolerance Re: True Position Tolerance VS Callout Tolerance -- brice arnold Post Reply Top of thread Forum
 Posted by: traingdt ® 12/10/2005, 10:37:23 Author Profile Mail author Edit The factor that the machine shop told you about is probably meant to convert diametrical tolerances to x-y tolerances, since that is what machines "think" in. But two points: first, I think the factor would be .0003535. This is calculated by assuming that the .001 position tolerance was a diameter; then cut that in half so the tolerance is now .0005 in any radial direction. Then use the Pythagorean Theorem to break that into vertical and horizontal components: .0005 = sqrt(x^2 + y^2). But the second point: realize that by doing this, they are cheating themselves out of a small portion of the tolerance zone. (Sketch a circular area and then a triangle from the center to the edge.) They are bounding themselves within a square zone that is inscribed within the full circle. But I suppose that's the tradeoff in converting back to x-y coordinates.

 Re: True Position Tolerance VS Callout Tolerance Re: True Position Tolerance VS Callout Tolerance -- brice arnold Post Reply Top of thread Forum
 Posted by: randykimball ® 12/09/2005, 19:19:52 Author Profile Mail author Edit Try this.../calculators.htm The worst suggestion of your lifetime may be the catalyst to the grandest idea of the century, never let suggestions go unsaid nor fail to listen to them.